Blog Detail

Page Title

Home / Blog / fortune Investment Blog Lump Sum or SIP Which is Better? Is SIP Method

Lump Sum or SIP Which is Better? Is SIP Method

  August 19,2021

Lump Sum or SIP Which is Better? Is SIP Method Always Better? Find out What the Data Shows…

SIP (Systematic Investment Plan) is the most popular name in the mutual fund industry, be it investor, advisor or fund house is concerned. The beauty of SIP is, inculcating the habit of disciplined investment, no doubt. In India, most of the mutual fund investors are retail investors and they can invest systematic only and SIP book size is ever growing.

Unfortunately, many investors as well as advisors, still believe SIP is the sure shot success or even if you have money better to invest in a staggered manner, rather than investing in lumpsum. As far as my reading goes, instead of looking at whether SIP is better or lump sum better, it is more of the fund availability when the investor is investing.

The point, I would like to emphasize here is, do not believe only SIP is better or it will create miracles. I have taken the last 5 years return of small cap and midcap funds which are very popular 5 years before and let’s look at how those funds performed in the past 5 years as lump sum as well as SIP.


Lump sum Returns in the last 5 Years in Small & Midcap Funds
Date DSP Small cap Franklin Smaller Co Reliance Small cap L&T Emerging HDFC Midcap
18-08-2014 28.61 30.15 19.42 11.8 29.91
16-08-2019 48.79 47.04 35.15 21.39 49.34
Abs. Gain in % 70.53% 56.02% 81.00% 81.27% 64.96%
CAGR. Gain in % 11.27% 9.30% 12.60% 12.63% 10.53%
SIP Investments in the last 5 Years in Small & Midcap Funds
SIP in 60 Months  ₹ 6,00,000  ₹  6,00,000  ₹ 6,00,000  ₹ 6,00,000  ₹ 6,00,000
Current Value  ₹ 6,08,599  ₹  6,18,758  ₹  6,79,961  ₹ 6,92,760  ₹  6,69,188
Abs. Gain in % 1.43% 3.13% 13.33% 15.46% 11.53%
CAGR. Gain in % 0.05% 0.10% 0.40% 0.46% 0.35%

Purpose of this article is to understand there is no fool proof method for investing. When we constantly look in to DATA we will find what works and what not. No point in following the strategy for all the time. Biggest myth is Doing Nothing is Good, when everything is dynamic Buy & Hold and not touching the portfolio will only affect the growth of the portfolio. It is high time to take action against the laggards rather than waiting for miracles to happen..


Fund Name Launch Date NAV Date Current Total SIP Investment SIP value as on XIRR CAGR
NAV Units Months Value 18-08-2019 (%) (%)
DSP Small Cap 14-06-2007 16-08-2019 48.79 12,473.86 60 6,00,000 6,08,599 0.56 0.05%
Franklin India Smaller Co 13-01-2006 16-08-2019 47.042 13,153.32 60 6,00,000 6,18,758 1.22 0.10%
Reliance Small Cap  16-09-2010 16-08-2019 35.1526 19,343.11 60 6,00,000 6,79,961 4.96 0.40%
L&T Emerging Businesses 12-05-2014 16-08-2019 21.396 32,378.03 60 6,00,000 6,92,760 5.7 0.46%
HDFC Mid-Cap Opportunities 25-06-2007 16-08-2019 49.348 13,560.60 60 6,00,000 6,69,188 4.32 0.35%

Tags : ,